wiki:symbol=t.b.d.
-
wiki:symbol=t.b.d. · Mateusz Konieczny (Gast) · 25.03.2022 12:32 · [flux]
https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Key%3Awiki%3Asymbol
I run into https://taginfo.openstreetmap.org/tags/ … alue=t.b.d.
For example on https://www.openstreetmap.org/relation/3030028
Would it be fine to remove
wiki:symbol=t.b.d.
or replace it with
fixme=add␣wiki:symbol
Sorry for English.
- Re: wiki:symbol=t.b.d. · Mateusz Konieczny (Gast) · 25.03.2022 12:35 · [flux]
Why it is problematic: such fake values require extra support and mismatch actual definition of this tag.
While being worse at its intended role than fixme.
I run into it while improving OSM Wiki documentation ( https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tal … d_bot_edit ) as this files were so far not clearly marked on OSM Wiki, and their use was unclear for OSM Wiki editors (some were deleted as unused).
wiki:symbol=todo
has the same issue.
BTW, there are some invalid values which have no matching file on OSM Wiki or Wikimedia Commons and never had it - is anyone interested in such list?
I also have list of values where name of file on OSM Wiki changed or files were deleted as unused duplicate of another file. I am slowly fixing such cases but I can give list to someone (I have approximately several thousands of known tagging issues on my list).
- Re: wiki:symbol=t.b.d. · user_5359 (Gast) · 25.03.2022 18:26 · [flux]
My opinion is that this change to the fixme entry makes sense for both value values. However, I would not recommend a mass update.
- Re: wiki:symbol=t.b.d. · Strubbl (Gast) · 09.04.2022 11:14 · [flux]
Mateusz Konieczny wrote:
Would it be fine to remove
No, please do not add a fixme, just remove this.
Mateusz Konieczny wrote:
is anyone interested in such list?
a list of invalid values? IMO invalid values can also be removed.
- Re: wiki:symbol=t.b.d. · mcliquid (Gast) · 09.04.2022 12:59 · [flux]
Strubbl wrote:
No, please do not add a fixme, just remove this.
I would have the same opinion. If no one has added it so far, a fixme won't necessarily bring that about either. If someone has a special interest in it, that person will find it even without fixme or t.b.d values.
Mateusz Konieczny wrote:
BTW, there are some invalid values which have no matching file on OSM Wiki or Wikimedia Commons and never had it - is anyone interested in such list?
I don't think a mere list is very beneficial. If it would trigger an issue at keepright or Osmose, that would make more sense in my humble view.